The Tragedy of the Commons (2011)

Robin Meier and Ali Momeni
Palais de Tokyo, from July 7 to September 18 2011
Curated by Marc Bembekof and Marc-Olivier Wahler
Supported by Pro Helvetia and LEEC Paris 13

[EN] The Tragedy of the Commons consists of a live experiment in the form of an installation, in which thousands of Atta ants – commonly known as leafcutter ants – create a choreography while reacting to certain flavours and smells expertly selected by Robin Meier and Ali Momeni with the help of the Laboratory of Comparative and Experimental Ethology of Paris 13 University. The installation is structured via three circular boards, all connected to one another either directly or through video surveillance and sound. The first of these, at the show’s entrance, is occupied by the ant colony and is physically linked to a second and central board through a long transparent tube; the insects move back and forth through this, accessing goods and bringing them to their nest. In this instance, the goods (or ‘commons’) are a mix of privet and rose leaves and petals, discharged daily onto the central ‘platter’. Contact microphones and cameras, set up on its entire surface, amplify the sound of the ants’ stridulation and offer live playback of their gleaning on a couple of monitors, installed – for closer observation – on the third and last board at the back of the room.

In other words, Meier and Momeni have created a metaphoric ‘food stock market’ for the ants, since every smell or flavour available becomes merchandise capable of affecting their collective behaviour. Accordingly the two artists, who share a background in electronic and experimental music, here manage to make audible and visible a mechanism of social manipulation. On the sonic level, the amplified sound within the installation space corresponds to the ants’ more or less sustained activity – which is particularly effective, grating and loud when, for example, rose petals and leaves are ‘served’ on the central ‘platter’; for, logically enough, the more the ants are fond of a certain flavour, the more greedily they cut that certain plant within their mandibles and, accordingly, the more noise they make. On the visual level, when the central board is flooded with goods – and the insects’ gleaning drastically intensified – quite stunning traffic jams occur in the tube that the ants use to bring food back to the colony.

The transition from the purely biological and ethological experiment to the social and political critical discourse is cleverly or thoughtfully supported by a few hints on paper: namely an atlas and an exchange rate (or currency) book that have been installed with the ‘commons’ on the central board and sprayed all over with natural scents such as orange blossom water. Inevitably the attractive smell of these two manuals leads the voracious ants to tear their pages to pieces. In this installation that evolves with a living colony, then, the symbolic mechanism of the capitalist market – which functions via the creation of demands that largely exceed the vital and primary needs of the population – manifests itself within an aesthetics of saturation, and therein appears the actual ‘tragedy of the commons’.

- Violaine Boutet de Monvel, Art Review, Issue 53, Oct. 2011

[FR] Tous deux de formation musicale, Robin Meier & Ali Momeni développent une pratique complexe où la science se mêle à une forme d’art hybride. En véritables éthologues, et en étroite collaboration avec scientifiques et laboratoires spécialisés, ils observent et manipulent le comportement de certaines espèces animales pour établir ensuite des dispositifs mécaniques et informatiques mettant en scène une interaction entre la machine et l’animal par le son.

The Tragedy of the Commons [La tragédie des biens communs] consiste en une installation où des milliers de fourmis Atta – surnommées fourmis coupe-feuilles – produisent une chorégraphie en réagissant à des couleurs et à des odeurs judicieusement choisies. Amplifié, le son des fourmis génère des textures sonores à l’image de leurs mouvements au sein d’une structure architecturale, acoustique et automatisée.

À travers une forme de conditionnement, les deux artistes créent un marché de valeurs et de coûts fictifs pour la nourriture des fourmis. En introduisant cette notion de valeur, une couleur ou une odeur est transformée en marchandise capable d’influencer le comportement collectif. Mêlant biologie et économie comportementale, Meier & Momeni rendent audibles les mécanismes cachés d’une manipulation sociale.

- Marc Bembekof, Palais de Tokyo, 2011

The Tragedy of the Commons a été conçue avec l’aide du Laboratoire d’Ethologie Expérimentale et Comparée de l’Université Paris 13 (LEEC).

L’apport quotidien en feuilles de rosiers non traités est rendu possible grâce à l’aimable participation de :
Direction des espaces verts et de l’environnement. Division du XVIe arrondissement de Paris (atelier des jardins du Trocadéro)
Musée Rodin, Paris